Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Oh, spare me the semantics, the difference is still single digit % of the total income.



How would a reader know that? And how can that be true when the brackets are so different? UK does not even look like it has single vs married distinctions, not to mention the myriad deductions in the US, and the drastically different taxes in various locales (I pay $30k+ less per year by living on the other side of a state/city border).

https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/taxes/federal-income-tax-...

https://www.gov.uk/income-tax-rates

The 45% UK income tax rate is for 150k GBP, which is $167k. The top bracket for US federal income tax starts at $578k/$693k at a 37% tax rate.

It does not seem to pencil out to being remotely close, and that is ignoring UK National insurance and pension tax rates, but I am not sure how UK pension works to equivocate to US FICA taxes.


I was providing my personal anecdotal experience of having the basically the same net income in 3 places. 37% federal tax also does not account for 6.8% state tax and the 3.8% NYC tax which I know does not apply to all of the US, but then we get into the territory where we have to address that I will probably not have same income in bumblefuck alabama anyway.

People here are talking like the difference between US taxes and EU taxes is 20% or more, when in reality it’s maybe 5%


The difference in tax burden is give here: https://data.oecd.org/tax/tax-revenue.htm . It varies quite a bit by country, but the contrast with France/Nordics is particularly large


I’m not sure how income tax % to GDP is relevant here, but perhaps I am looking at a wrong thing, it’s quite painful on mobile

UPD: looked at the tax wedge, the US vs UK looks pretty similar to me- which supports my point. Germany looks a lot higher, but they have 100% free tuition and I am not familiar with the rest of the benefits germans get.


A single digit % of total income may not be a big deal in European salary terms, but when you make US salaries it's significant. That's your first mistake.

Also, lol at UK public transit. Horrifically expensive - probably more than a single digit % of total income if you actually have to commute anywhere on a regular basis.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: