Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is the reason the Semantic Web never took off—people on the internet can't even agree on what a "sandwich" is, let alone the exact hierarchy of ontology.

This is an area where large language models have a role to play—whatever you're hoping to achieve with user-generated tags can probably be achieved with ML-powered associations or navigation. And the potential benefit is that it could be tailored to each user—so you're only surfacing "Hot Dogs" when certain users click "Sandwich."



I thought that the cube rule of food generally settled the sandwich debate. A hot dog is not a type of sandwich, being surrounded on three sides. Instead, it is a type of taco.


Haha yes, and I would hate to meet the Turing-complete tagging system that could capture this nuance!


This is what we do for the most part. Two tiers of 'tags'. One is curated and required, the other is an embedding.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: