Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

That’s what consulates are. An actual police station is way different.



No you're getting confused, and have it backwards.

These Chinese police patrol around tourist areas with local police. You don't go to a consulate when you lose your mobile phone or someone steals your wallet.

These are police who operate in concert with local police. The whole point is to help Chinese tourists I think. It's not for anything nefarious...It's too racist to be smearing everything Chinese under the banner of the current Western-'China-bogeyman'-hysteria


Is this sort of thing common? Do other countries place police forces in other sovereign nations with the intent to help their home country's tourists get around in a foreign land? If not, then I think we need to look at this as an aberration, with scrutiny, and assume the worst until proven otherwise.

I personally think it is outrageous that the US government (or state or local governments) allows China to station police officers on US soil, and gives them the right to act in a police capacity. I am not ok with that at all, even if what you suggest as their purpose is correct.

Why would this even be necessary, if they're here for the purpose you suggest? Local police can handle these sorts of cases, and cities where tourists tend to travel certainly have translators on staff. Hell, cities in the US have translators to help with residents whose English skills are poor.

Also: it's not "racist" to dislike this sort of thing if the foreign government in question is not aligned values-wise with your own. I don't think it's remotely appropriate for an authoritarian anti-democratic country to have law enforcement influence on our soil.

I wouldn't have the same reaction if, say, a tight US ally (South Korea or Japan, to pick examples from the same part of the world) were to have an informal police presence in the US. But even then, I would expect them to be working with the FBI (or similar) on higher-level international crime matters (sorta like an Interpol type thing), not working on local crime. Foreign police forces should not have any kind of jurisdiction in "local" crimes.


I know there are British policemen in Thailand, there is even a reality show of it. I am not following this topic, so this is the one I know.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: