Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

China technically doesn’t recognize dual citizenship for anyone over 18. But they’ve been known to rescind someone rescinding their citizenship before, which is messed up.


> they’ve been known to rescind someone rescinding their citizenship

I'm trying to figure out what you mean here, and wondering if you have a typo. Would you please elaborate?


This case: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/feb/25/gui-minhai-det...

> The court in Ningbo acknowledged Gui had become Swedish in the 1990s but added that he had applied to restore his Chinese citizenship in 2018. China does not recognise dual citizenship and restoring his Chinese passport may have been a way to block Swedish diplomats from visiting him, observers said.

That was after he was detained (china kidnapped him in Thailand).


> they’ve been known to rescind someone rescinding their citizenship

...

> he had applied to restore his Chinese citizenship in 2018

Unless I'm misreading this, or if the latter claim is false, these are two very different scenarios, no?


Gui was kidnapped in 2015, so his "application" to restore Chinese citizenship in 2018 was almost certainly not exactly voluntary.


My take is that even if you rescind your Chinese citizenship, the CCP can choose to un-rescind it, re-exposing you to Chinese authority.


And then they can "persuade" you to return to China, where they don't recognize your dual citizenship.


... but this just give you dual citizenship.


That doesn't help you if they have you in China and keep you from getting access to an embassy. Dual citizenship only helps if they actually recognize it, or your host country learns of your plight- neither of which are the case here.


*home country. Host country is the one persecuting.


This might just be my own strange way of thinking.

I haven't actual lived in my parents house in decades, and yet when I go there to visit them I still think of it as "going home".

In the case above, I assume we are talking about people born in China, who have left to live in another country, and are then involuntarily returned to China. In my head, China is still the home country.

All of that said, having read your comment, I just now realized that is and uncommon understanding of the words. Your interpretation is certainly closer to the emotional meaning of them for the people involved.


Generally speaking, if you are a citizen of country X and you are in country X accused of violating the laws of country X then any citizenship of country Y that you might have is irrelevant.


It's true even if you aren't a citizen of X. Griner isn't escaping prison by not being a Russian citizen. Neither are all the kidnapped Ukrainian children.


OK, but Griner at least receives consular assistance from the US government - she wouldn't even get that if she were a Russian dual-national.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: