Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Who cares? It's not like a packet that's a result of sharing/reselling suddenly "weighs" more on the network wires.



> Who cares?

The people purchasing these hot spots, who find their bankruptcy claims against Helium being inhibited by intentional breach of contract.

> not like a packet that's a result of sharing/reselling suddenly "weighs" more

It does due to peering arrangements. Data transfer having value is also Helium’s claimed value added. It’s awkward to claim it costs nothing to implement but has value that can be sustainably charged.


You probably don't want someone distributing something like child porn over your home network


People running the hotspots should care, they could get prosecuted for unauthorized access of their ISPs network. Sharing you connection is not authorized. Don't like it, lobby to change the law but what they are doing is explicitly illegal.


The odds of that happening is negligible.

I suppose ISPs could try to make an example of a few customers. But I think that would be horrible PR as well as very difficult to prove.

How would they distinguish traffic that’s authorized and unauthorized? As their customer, how much do you think I can authorize? Can I grant my guests access? Can my smart lightbulbs access?




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: