Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> crashes

I've literally never had or heard of Slack crashing, across Windows, Ubuntu and macOS, regardless of memory available (8-32GB) and use. Do people really have Slack regularly crash on them or is that just something that gets attached to Electron (for some reason).



A slack crash would be the window going white and reloading.

I get them occasionally.

An electron crash would kill the window. I get these sometimes too when I try to run natively in wayland, which I’m aware is unsupported so I’m not blaming anyone for that.


Happens to folks on my team on occasion. Slack crashing. And the whole Electron app crashing too. Linux users.


Slack crashes on my Ubuntu setup on the regular.

Grey screens. Unresponsive during video calls. Eats all of my memory at least once a day. The app is a mess.


Not a single crash on Mac in 5 months I’ve been using it. Perhaps it’s the Linux version? Or your system?


Slack crashes quite often for me-try to do too much? That’s a crash.

Accidentally toggled the “huddle” button a couple of times - it’ll crash so badly, I legitimately have to restart the computer to fix it.


You’ve never seen Slack reload while using it? Often, that’s a “crash” in an Electron app.


I have not seen that. It's crash-free for me, running 24x7.

But all that tells you is that it's crash-free on at least a small % of machines, so not a great way to analyze robustness. Maybe create an HN poll?


> I have not seen that.

No offense, but you must have blinders on then. On a fresh install on a new machine it’ll do it in the first day.

> It's crash-free for me, running 24x7.

There was a person who legit got struck by lightning multiple times in their life and lived, so anything is possible. Your claim is comparatively improbable though, but still has the possibility of being true.


I get them all the time on my M1 Mac (Like at least once a week.) Sometimes even the white window that requires a force quit and doesn't auto-reload.


I have experienced few crash like scenario with network issues on my Mac. If my wifi is poor for a minute, slack will permanently stop working unless I force reload using menu or restart it. Messaging apps are basically meant to not have permanent connection, but I have seen very few that could work with this assumption.


Slack regularly crashes with an empty window on my Mac. Not like a process crash, but the whole window going empty, needing to quit the process and reopen.


Slack crashes (unresponsive white window -> hard reload) for me at least once a day on the latest MacOS and Intel MBP, and it seems a common occurrence for many of the coworkers I talk to.


I’ve never seen one on Mac OS Slack




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: