Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Anyway, I don't see anything in the article about what the academic office said when he turned all those reports in. I'm really curious, these kinds of situations tend to make national news when some prof brings a large number of students up on academic honor code violations. (ex: https://www.military.com/daily-news/2021/08/20/least-100-nav...)

I'm firmly of the opinion that the negatives of group study out weight the positives and generally should be banned in college. Banging your head against a problem for hours at a time assures you understand all the wrong ways of getting the right answer. This means you have a far more detailed understanding, and there is always formal academic study/the prof/etc and the possibility of asking about difficulties in class.

And finally, group chat is small potato's, I'm fairly certain there is a fair bit of 3rd parties basically doing assignments/taking tests these days for students. Primary because I was "mentoring" a student in a subject and found myself in a situation that I had to extract myself from because it crossed a line of mine.




> I'm firmly of the opinion that the negatives of group study out weight the positives and generally should be banned in college

That's a... strong opinion.

I'm genuinely at a loss of how you can think that. If studying in groups was harmful enough to be banned by colleges, then shouldn't online classes have been tremendous boons to learning? On a personal level, I can barely straighten out two thoughts in my head unless I have someone I can talk it over with, I couldn't imagine collaborative study being outright banned.

Am I missing something here?


> I'm fairly certain there is a fair bit of 3rd parties basically doing assignments/taking tests these days for students.

I can confirm this.

Personally, I have seen as high as 10 %, but those numbers were heavily skewed towards students who could only speak Chinese. Not sure what was up with them.

I do not teach anymore, but I have heard that the situation became much worse in the last few years.


The tuition rates paid by foreign governments on behalf of some International students is astronomical and hard to be ethical about.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: