Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

FED / SEC are completely different entities with completely different roles and market functions. It's like apples and oranges. And has nothing to do with a VAT tax.

I am sorry, but your comment is almost incoherent - so my response is more of a broad general definition of what the Federal Reserve is doing to help you understand the macro context a bit more. As the Fed actions are intentionally moving the markets / economy at this point.

Short form - the Federal Reserve increasing the cost of money slows down demand in the entire economy as a function of the cost of money goes up. I am not talking only hard goods - we are talking services, investments etc. They want to slow down the demand side of the economy by increasing the cost of money. It's a blunt tool but it works - if it works to well we enter into a recession which is why they are in the hot seat right now. Very challenging as they have a simple lever where there is a considerable amount of factors (geopolitics, other countries central banks etc).

Hope that helps.



You are not addressing the fact that their lever deincentivize investment and therefore production, an argument worsening inflation and you are not addressing my point saying that VAT is obviously a direct measure to reduce demand, without impacting investment as directly, finally my VAT locality on the most critically underproducing sector yet non affecting the unaffected companies that produce just fine, is a third argument. This is pretty basic. The answer is more likely to be that the U.S never had a VAT and creating one has tragic political inertia and hence the FED use the wrong tool but the one it dispose.


I didn't respond to you argument because it was incoherent and unrelated:

Why are you even discussing VATs? Politically infeasible and not a tool at the disposal of the Fed - its at the disposal of the legislature. Also it doesn't solve the problem that the Fed has - which is reducing money supply / offloading its balance sheet and reducing inflation without tanking the labor market.


We have that. They’re called automatic stabilizers. There are a ton of them. For example, when people make more money, they pay a higher tax rate.


Is this the sort of analysis that led to the invention of social credit by C.H. Douglas?




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: