Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> it makes sense that if coinbase goes bankrupt, the customer currencies will go away as well

Others have said this, but just to reiterate : this is quite wrong. This is like saying that because you hold Amazon stock via a Schwab brokerage account, if Schwab were to declare bankruptcy, then you would lose your Amazon stock. Needless to say that wouldn't happen because you are the owner of the stock, not Schwab.

FDIC insurance covers a totally different scenario where the money you deposit doesn't really exist (lent to someone else in the meantime).

What makes sense is that Coinbase isn't the owner of customers' crypto assets. This thread is about the fact that apparently that's _not_ necessarily true.



There's no FDIC or other protections in play here, except for the small amount of money a customer might have in "cash", held by Coinbase pending or resulting from a crypto transaction.

Once you buy a bitcoin, you have a digital good, not money/currency (as defined by most governments/courts -- which is the point that matters here)

If you buy a skin in Fortnite, and Fortnite goes under, you no longer have that skin, even it if was made by another player and put on a public marketplace offered by Fortnite. You can't get Forenite to return that skin to you, and you can't ask the author to send you a copy to save.

If Coinbase goes under, the crypto would likely be treated as digital goods by the court, not as "currency".. or perhaps that case would solidify crypto's definition as a security or currency... but I'd argue that it's unclear right now, and that creditors would want Coinbase to liquidate the digital assets to pay off employees, creditors first.


> Others have said this, but just to reiterate : this is quite wrong. This is like saying that because you hold Amazon stock via a Schwab brokerage account, if Schwab were to declare bankruptcy, then you would lose your Amazon stock. Needless to say that wouldn't happen because you are the owner of the stock, not Schwab.

But that isn't how Coinbase works. They aren't holding a share for you, they are holding your actual assets, with nothing in force that they would have to return them, bar what is in USD.


You might wanna check the fine print on your Schwab brokerage account.


Not sure what you are insinuating but the Schwab fine print definitely says that the customer assets are not Schwabs (because that's the rules of the regulatory environment they work in). No court in the US would would use customer shares to settle Schwab debt.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: