Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> You may notice that the US population has grown, and continues to grow, and the abstract group comprised of "people who rent homes" continue to grow, and to need more to rent.

"People who rent homes" aren't some special type of consumer that isn't interested in buying a home. While there are situations where renting is preferable even if it's possible to buy, many renters only rent because it's not possible for them to buy a home. Any potential benefits to renting are generally outweighed by the fact that you're not building any equity, and have limited control over the place they live.

Massive corporate landlords aren't providing a service to meet a demand. They're actively creating demand by driving up the cost of home ownership, and limiting the amount of properties available to buy. A potential homeowner has no chance of competing with a massive corporation when buying a home.

Obviously there's a huge amount of factors that got us here. Housing is hugely complicated, and no single group is responsible. But corporate landlords are one of the factors making the North American housing market worse, and are one of the things we need to address if we're ever going to decrease the cost of living in this country.



> Massive corporate landlords aren't providing a service to meet a demand. They're actively creating demand by driving up the cost of home ownership

This accusation would make a lot of sense if the corporations in question are either (a) a monopoly or (b) an illegal trust, colluding with each other, and through (a) or (b) the corporations enjoyed sufficient concentration of the housing sector that they had pricing power — the ability to restrict the supply and raise prices to make money.

This is not the case. The housing market is fairly competitive, and many different buyers, sellers, homeowners, and home-builders participate and compete with each other. Prices are rising for other reasons: a reduced number of homebuilders, in the aftermath of the 2008 crash; various political land-use, zoning, environmental, and similar homebuilding restrictions; a reduction in the overall labor pool, which impacts the labor in new home construction; labor and other supply chain impacts on the availability of components that are used in new home construction; and a significant pandemic-induced shift in real estate usage patterns (almost everyone wants more space now).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: