Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Googler Builds Site That Shows You What Top Tech Companies Pay (techcrunch.com)
75 points by Bartlet on Sept 30, 2011 | hide | past | favorite | 21 comments



The problem with all salary sites (Payscale.com, Salary.com, Glassdoor.com) is the reliability of the data that they're pulling from. They all make such gross exaggerations and generalizations of salaries across locales, industries and titles that I'm sure you could reduce an entry-level statistician to tears.

Given that this site is based on "open sources of information publicly available to anyone on the internet," I think it is just a rehashing of the same, polluted information that's plagued salary discussions for a decade. I had initially hoped that, coming from a Googler, there'd be some new intelligence brought to organizing and interpreting the data. No such luck.

The best source of accurate salary discussions still comes from sites like http://salaryshare.me/ (previously discussed on HN: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2441888)


> in the Vegas analogy I’m Hunter S. Thomson

No, you are not.


Maybe for the drugs


The salary listed for my position at my company is 27k less than I make. I'm not sure if these numbers accurately reflect the true average salary of all employees. I find it very hard to believe that my salary is that much higher than average.


The site is http://techcompanypay.com/

It is currently down.


i could reach it right now..


same here...


I wonder if these estimates are calculated using overall compensation (which includes stock and bonuses) or base salary? Does anyone know?


From my personal experience, it has to be base. Those numbers are way too low to be total comp.


Article mentions that it's likely H1B wages. I suppose that's base salary, not including stocks and bonuses?


Im not from the USA, so I wonder what "Twitter paying $120K on average" actually means. After Taxes etc, how much of what the company pays will end up in the employees pocket to actually buy sutff?


In the major urban areas (Cali, NY) about 50% (with quite a big margin - more correct would be 'between 40 and 55%), excluding health care insurance.

(I'm not in the US but I have an academic interest in comparative tax pressures, and that of the US comes up quite often).


Where do you think are hot spots with a good supply of tech jobs, where taxes on the individual is low and rent is not very high?


Austin, TX.


Indianapolis, IN


Not sure he meant a literal hot spot.


I stopped reading this entry at "Hunter S. Thomson." [sic]


If it's based on H1B datasets, it's mostly incorrect. H1B salaries are definitely lower than what US citizens get (on average).


Possibly true, though for the same position it will be the same pay. Having managed H1B employees, every year I was required to fill out a bunch of paperwork confirming that I was not underpaying them for their work relative to their peers. We were fairly rigorous about this.

That said, you're only on an H1B visa until you get your green card. By which point, you've gone through several promotions and are finally leaving the junior engineer position. I would also expect H1B numbers to be skewed lower for this reason.

If people really want to know what the salaries are at other companies, they should just make friends with their generalist. Big company HR orgs pay third parties to do more stastically rigorous surveys of salaries by position and use that to determine how "not to overpay."


My relatives went through the H1B process. I know exactly how employers treat them. They understand that you're tied to them, and even though you could transfer, it resets your greencard process.

My father was making less money than the people under him, even though he was the chief engineer (vs regular engineers).


H1B salaries are generally higher. Perhaps they are confusing billing rate with salary rate.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: