Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Implying they could have earned that money without the existence of government. Government is an essential service.


> without the existence of government.

paying less taxes doesn't imply that the gov't ceases to exist. The gov't has no competition, so every entity within the gov't has every incentive to increase their own revenue by maximally expending tax dollars.

It is up to the people paying taxes to reduce it, as a counter-balancing force, and hold the spending efficiency to a good standard.


It’s not implying anything. That is literally how taxes work. See income taxes: A compensatory agreement between employer and employee is I pay you $X for work. The government then levies a percentage of that money for itself. You can see that on your paystub. You’re not paid $X and an amount equal to a percentage of $X is then donated to the government, that percentage comes directly from your compensation.

It’s a revenue stream for governments, sure, but how much revenue a government needs is determined by what policies a government has in place, their obligations to pay employees and officers, and what additional services the government offers. The politics is all around that stuff, but a tax is still a taking of the money that someone else earned to pay for all that, including to pay public employees.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: