Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Their motives might be suspect, but their goals are admirable. There is no reason every state payment shouldn’t be public.


Pick your allies carefully.

I flirted with a transparency org. Washington Citizens for Open Government.

The libertarian minded (Discovery Institute, Toby Nixon, Paul Guppy, so many others) used these nonpartisan good govt orgs to advocate their religion. It was maddening.

For instance, simultaneously advocating transparency AND privatization, without irony. Corporations are not subject to public records requests. Many an agency outsourced work to keep the activities away from public scrutiny. Anyone with a sincere desire for good govt advocates for less outsourcing, less privatization.

By all means, advocate for better stuff. Just know the opponents of democratic civil society will always highjack, subvert, project, argue in bad faith. The paradox of tolerance, on endless repeat.

I have no ideas how to avoid that trap. A large part of my burn out as an activist.


"Anyone with a sincere desire for good govt advocates for less outsourcing, less privatization."

"Just know the opponents of democratic civil society will always highjack, subvert, project, argue in bad faith."

The only bad faith displayed here is yours.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: