Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

No, that would not be a smart approach. Then you can only drive where beacons are installed.

If you have no problem with humans driving by hoping they find the right pixels on their retinas, why would you worry about AI doing the same? If anything, AI has a perfect reaction, is never tired or sleepy or unattentive. It just needs to be taught properly.



> Then you can only drive where beacons are installed

Uh no, then you can only use automated driving systems where beacons are installed.


"It just needs to be taught properly."

So just like all miracle solutions, .i.e. communism, every time we tried it, we just weren't doing it right.


Technology, not miracle. It's being actively worked on, and there's an undeniable progress. YouTube has plenty of videos of Tesla's self driving system and its progress over the years is very obvious.


No, the problem is that AI systems are unpredictable, unverifiable, and their correctness is unprovable. There is a million academic articles detailing this issue.

When we need something that works 99.99999% of the time, it is written in ADA or similar safe language and tested exhaustively. You know how long processing will take to the microsecond, you use a special realtime OS, etc.

AI will have its own failings, some of them totally unpredictable, so yes, boiling it down to 'just needs to be trained properly' is terrifying when peoples lives are at stake

Look at this attack, and tell me how is this goonf to be avoided with 'proper training' https://www.theregister.com/2018/01/11/ai_adversarial_attack...


> the problem is that AI systems are unpredictable, unverifiable, and their correctness is unprovable.

Same can be said about humans.

None of what you listed matters in the real world. Self-driving systems just have to be better than average humans, on average, to be useful.

> boiling it down to 'just needs to be trained properly' is terrifying when peoples lives are at stake

You have no problem with humans being trained to drive. 38.6 thousand people died in car crashes in the US alone last year.


An AI which “just needs to be taught properly” is the same as a genie or magic pixie which also exist but for “just needing to be taught properly”




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: