Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> So the ISR drones will see the launch site or platform and it will get hit by missiles

The "launch site" is any spot of land near the coast accessible by a truck.

The ISR satellites pick up launches by ballistic missiles that rise up high in the atmosphere, which have a very large IR signature. The sats are not going to pick up a gas-powered small aircraft, even if you use a small solid rocket for launch assist.

Also, you're going to want to re-think the economics of this, if you're using a $100K USD missile to destroy a $10K pickup truck on a regular basis. Nevermind the cost (like the aircraft hours) needed to get the missile on-target. Nevermind that the enemy can field 10 times the number of trucks that you have aircraft, at 100 times less cost.



Yes I understand it’s a hard problem but swarms of drones that threaten the USA, will be fought with swarms of American drones right? You can launch drones from the carriers searching for potential launch points etc.

Commercial satellite picked up an f15 banking in Gaza recently, so the ability to imagine and scan in near real-time the land and sea around carrier strike groups and other valuable assets and locations seems likely.

Other way to think about the costs are a 1 million dollar missile that takes out a $5000 rocket that’s being used to threaten billions of dollars of ships, thousands of lives, a potential ecological disaster if one sinks, and the ships are defending or “liberating” billions or trillions of dollars in resources and shipping.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: