Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

He is hinting at the conspiracy theory that Soviets had a previous unsuccessful attempt when the cosmonaut died.

While the USSR was fairly secretive and during its existence, a successful hush-up of a major screw-up was at least possible, we would have learnt about it since 1991.



Even before 1991 many of these theories could be disproved.

James Oberg was uncovering info about phantom or missing cosmonauts in the early 70s, including photos of the original class of Cosmonauts before & after some were airbrushed out. At least 5 men were removed from the photos and they have all been traced (Grigoriy Nelyubov being the most high profile as a member of the "Sochi Six") despite Soviet space officials going to significant lengths to excise these men from their history.

Since the Fall of the Soviet Union we've had revelation after revelation about embarrassing episodes in Soviet history (including previously covered up issues with Vostok 1 during its flight), yet we've discovered nothing about further missing cosmonauts. Of course there could be much better covered up episodes, I'd just expect we'd know a hell of a lot more about them by now.

(As an aside, this info is from Oberg's 1988 book "Uncovering Soviet Disasters" which has _fascinating_ little passages about how much more open the Soviet Union has been "recently" with regards to publicising disasters under Glasnost and how that will continue into the future. So interesting to see as someone born shortly after the fall of the Soviet Union.)


This was the first human to die in a space flight: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vladimir_Komarov

Apparently the USSR told the story as: he kept sending back scientific data up to the last moment.

PS. They definitely hid some of their failures, but I don't think it would have been possible with loss of life involved.


Radio communication monitoring would have gave it away


Why 1991? Even though USSR collapsed, whatever was sealed, is still sealed to this day.


>Why 1991? Even though USSR collapsed, whatever was sealed, is still sealed to this day.

Some documents are sealed but many were declassified since then.


People talk. A lot. And the post-1990 economic situation in Russia was so bad that at least some of the surviving witnesses would be tempted to sell the story.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: