Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Wordpress makes sense if the goals are:

- Big upfront design

- Leverage existing plugins to minimize new development

- Use managed hosting

- Hand off to non-technical or semi-technical people and spin down development to just occasional contract work

If you actually have a FTE developer, it doesn’t fit as well at all. Among other problems, it does not work with a git centric development flow, which any modern dev will insist on.




Eh, the efficiencies you describe happen regardless of whether the dev team is full-time or outsourced, and I think there are ways of doing git flows with WP.


> it does not work with a git centric development flow, which any modern dev will insist on.

Yes, it does. Just use Trellis and Bedrock.


I am not familiar with them, but a quick Google seems to suggest they won’t work with WPEngine, Wordpress.com, etc. In any event, they’re bolt on solutions, but the core of Wordpress is still a mess of configuration split between files on disk and the database. There is nothing so valuable about Wordpress that you couldn’t just get a more reliable solution from scratch than by bolting more stuff onto WP. I’ve heard people say “oh, our users are already trained on WP, so it’s a good CMS” but I don’t buy that at all. I’ve had users praise my homegrown CMSes before. There’s not much difficulty in pairing a WYSIWYG text editor and some form fields with modern web stacks these days.


> “oh, our users are already trained on WP, so it’s a good CMS” but I don’t buy that at all. I’ve had users praise my homegrown CMSes before. There’s not much difficulty in pairing a WYSIWYG text editor and some form fields with modern web stacks these days.

I don't think even the admin UI is well organised or consistent though. Most users just know how to create and edit posts. Once you start installing a few required plugins too, the UI becomes even more a mess of controls that users are scared to touch.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: