Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Because cats don't think in collective myths and build cities.

Humans don't think with insect-like sub-brains throughout their body.

The title of the article has "human" in it so it makes sense to have a human-centric discussion about it.



You missed my point. I wasn't claiming that cows are as smart as humans. I was claiming that evolution has produced millions of species, only 1 of which is humans. So you can't just handwave "evolution" to validate human thinking.

Humans are likely smarter than all of the other animals, but that's a pretty low bar. The competition for "smartest Earth species" is fairly weak.


No I didn't. "Every organism alive now evolved over millions of years" but they are still very distinct.

> you can't just handwave "evolution"

If you believe the brain is part of the body, and that the body evolved, you believe _some_ part of evolutionary psychology. It's not handwaving.

That part of the article suggests that societal unrest creates say, fascist leaders, and not the other way around.


> No I didn't.

Yes, you did, because you seem to continue to think that I was arguing against the article, when in fact I was merely arguing against the comment by amadeuspagel that I replied to.

amadeuspagel was arguing against the article, claiming that these thought patterns shouldn't necessarily be considered "flaws", because they're the product of evolution. I dispute that, because non-human thinking, which we all consider to be inferior, is also a product of evolution. That's what I meant by handwaving. I do believe that humans are smarter, but I also believe that human thinking is very far from perfect, still heavily flawed. As are all products of evolution.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: