Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

heroku is a PaaS, it could be running containers internally, you wouldn't know. docker, k8s and the other tools are just building blocks of a PaaS, you are comparing oranges to a full course meal.


Sure, but the point is that by running your own K8S you're running a cloud provider. Which is fine, if your business is being a cloud provider. If not, let someone else do it, they'll be better at it.


My startup would have gone bankrupt a couple of years ago if we would use something as expensive as Heroku. Or AWS.


Genuinely curious what you were doing. Renting your own racks in a DC, providing reliable networking, paying upfront for all the servers and then hiring staff for just managing all this bare metal is insanely expensive for a startup. How is not using cloud a cheaper option?


We're renting bare metal servers from Hetzner. It's multiple times cheaper than AWS. We have lots of data, and to handle it with no problems our DB server has 512 GB of RAM and 24 cores (AMD EPYC). How much does it cost to have a comparable server on AWS? More than $2k per month, last time I checked.

We bootstrapped the startup and I'm based in a much cheaper area than SF or NY (Eastern Europe, actually). I can hire a decent developer here for $2k per month.


Can you share your company ?


I've sent you an email to the contacts in your profile.


Okay so you're still using Cloud service but with a different layer of abstraction. It's not the same as on-prem Bare metal which usually people refer to as "not using cloud"


There are options in the middle of "shared hosting" & "build your own cpu".


Yep, I haven't said I'm "not using cloud", I said I don't use Heroku or AWS because they're expensive.


This is to me a very scary comment. It says "we have no idea how computers work". Source: run a service on bare metal in a rack in a DC that I haven't entered in a year or more.


What is your scale? How much does it cost? What happens when your rack or DC goes down? All of this is not worth it for small-mid size companies. This is why the cloud took off in the first place. The revenue of AWS, Azure, GCP speaks for itself.


So much IT is relatively easy in the singular.

It's the plural that teases out the differences between the pets and the cattle.

And maybe that's the point of this thread: scalability.


Scaling what though?


Any system.


Yes, dynos are containers; their use of containers predates Docker.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: