Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

No, that’s a problem with their sentence construction.

All it means is that among African American blacks, males were the majority.

The key is:

""African American males made up the majority of protesters in the four observed cities vs. females,”"

vs. females (when looking at male-female distribution in the African American pop of protesters, in those four cities the majority were men).



"African American males made up the majority of protesters "

This is very clear. No idea what you are talking about.


Ethnicity Distribution:

A substantial majority of the protesters were white, in the cities where the data was gathered, with the highest percentage in Minneapolis (85%), followed by Los Angeles (78%), and Atlanta and New York (both at 76%). A total of 18% of the protesters were African American in Atlanta, 11% in Minneapolis, 13% in New York and 3% in Los Angeles. Those numbers remained steady during the nighttime hours. Hispanic and Asian American participation was less than 10% in all four cities.

https://www.mobilewalla.com/about/press/new-report-reveals-d...


Marc1 says>"Ethnicity Distribution: A substantial majority of the protesters were white, in the cities where the data was gathered, with the highest percentage in Minneapolis (85%), followed by Los Angeles (78%), and Atlanta and New York (both at 76%). A total of 18% of the protesters were African American in Atlanta, 11% in Minneapolis, 13% in New York and 3% in Los Angeles. Those numbers remained steady during the nighttime hours. Hispanic and Asian American participation was less than 10% in all four cities.

https://www.mobilewalla.com/about/press/new-report-reveals-d...

Again, nothing you say here can be found at the URL you provided. In fact the words "male", "female" and even "%" do not exist at that URL.


They moved/removed the doc. Here's the link of the cached copy [ https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:pX1Cst...] and text:

>"Ethnicity Distribution: A substantial majority of the protesters were white, in the cities where the data was gathered, with the highest percentage in Minneapolis (85%), followed by Los Angeles (78%), and Atlanta and New York (both at 76%). A total of 18% of the protesters were African American in Atlanta, 11% in Minneapolis, 13% in New York and 3% in Los Angeles. Those numbers remained steady during the nighttime hours. Hispanic and Asian American participation was less than 10% in all four cities.

Male vs. Female During the daytime hours, the majority of Black Lives Matter protesters were male in Atlanta (58%), Minneapolis (56%) and New York (62%). However, in Los Angeles, the greatest number of protesters during daytime were women. At nighttime, the percentage of male protesters increased in all four cities.

African American Males vs. Females African American males made up the majority of protesters in the four observed cities vs. females. Men vs. women in Atlanta (61% vs. 39%), in Los Angeles (65% vs. 35%), in Minneapolis (54% vs. 46%) and in New York (59% vs. 41%). There was no statistical change for the nighttime hours.

How Old Were the Protesters? The overall age of the protesters in all four cities skewed heavily in the 18-34 age ranging from 66% in New York and L.A., 67% in Minneapolis to 69% in Atlanta. Protesters in the 55+ age group ranked second ranging from 24% in New York, 23% in Atlanta and Minneapolis to 20% in Los Angeles."


Then either their pie charts are wrong/mislabeled or their prose writing sucks. Compare the two.


The full sentence you're quoting makes things a bit murkier to me: "African American males made up the majority of protesters in the four observed cities vs. females,"


possibly more clear to say something like: "for African American protesters the majority, xx%, were males." If that's what they're trying to say.


That's not how language works. You can't freely remove words from a sentence and assets that the meaning remains the same.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: