Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> That would imply they are incompetent and negligent.

Not really.

Product Manager: I want to be able to support Facebook login for our app.

Developer: OK... [googles for how to do that] ... We can use the FB SDK for that.

PM: Cool, let's do that.

Dev: [implements it]

Nobody really does much more due diligence than that most of the time. I suppose you could argue that's negligent, but if that's the case, then pretty much every company that has an app with login functionality is probably in that boat.



> I suppose you could argue that's negligent, but if that's the case, then pretty much every company that has an app with login functionality is probably in that boat.

I think every company that does this is negligent. Audit your dependencies, people!


As nice as it would be, auditing everything you use is almost impossible, especially for smaller teams.


See, one way I often solve this is by reducing my reliance on third-party dependencies.


Which is also a hard thing to do on small teams.

I think for small teams this is a near impossible task. For big corporations it should be doable and expected. They actually have some leverage to push the other big companies to track less. Something a small company simply can't do.


Is this really a compelling argument for the given case? A detailed audit does not seem necessary here:

This is not some surprising behaviour hidden in some random dependency.

This is the Facebook SDK, from Facebook, and everybody knows what their business is.


> This is the Facebook SDK, from Facebook, and everybody knows what their business is.

Ignorance is a bliss. Talk to some people that still use fb after their scandal and you'll get "who cares, everyone is tracking users and selling data anyway" as an answer.


Exactly. A simple online search for the phrase "Facebook SDK" will reveal plenty. It's not like you need forensic accounting level research to see that the SDK does much more than provide a simple login mechanism.


It really isn't. Full stop.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: