Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> salary disclosure destroys value for people with negotiating skills, which are among the most valuable and useful skills of all.

The world would be a very very shitty place if we had to negotiate for everything on an individual basis. It's much more efficient to find the few people who actually have that skill and let them do it for the group (and we can spend more time actually trying to fucking improve the human species well-being instead of bickering on $$s).

> Disclosure absolves managers of the need to negotiate effectively, which means you get managers who can't negotiate, which is the worst possible outcome for a company, since what is their job again?

uh.. ensuring that their team is productive by handling their well-being issues ?



> It's much more efficient to find the few people who actually have that skill and let them do it for the group

And human nature being what it is, why won't those few people negotiate better deals for themselves while keeping peanuts for the rest? (see: class action layers, bosses of Unions etc).


For the same reason any similar arrangement holds: if it gets bad enough, the torches and pitchforks come out and the group finds themselves a new negotiator.


> why won't those few people negotiate better deals for themselves while keeping peanuts for the rest?

Because they would be very bad negotiators and wouldn't be hired in the first place.

And because they probably are scamming the rest of the group, which is a crime in most developed countries.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: