Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Once they got Watson performing well enough... understatement of the year.


Is it heretical to say that for a project that researchers have been working on for six years, Watson performs as well as I would expect?

They have a ton of priors, a ton of specific optimizations, and a lot of resources.

It's pretty impressive but in a they-clearly-worked-a-lot-on-this way, not a what's-their-secret kind of way, you know?


It's pretty impressive but in a they-clearly-worked-a-lot-on-this way, not a what's-their-secret kind of way, you know?

If this isn't a "what's their secret kind of way" then what is, in your opinion? Or are you just more of the pragmatic, if its been done then obviously it could be done, duh.


It just seems like what I would expect, although I give them full credit for tackling this challenge in the first place. I'm not the only one:

http://www.madpickles.org/rokjoo/2011/02/14/ibm-watson-vs-go...


Well this guy is a Google employee, so his bias is obvious. But I'm not optimistic about Google if most of their employees can't differentiate between the difficulties in doing database queries and constructing an answer from a question. It's a FAR bigger jump than when we went to Google from Alta Vista -- especially since, coincidentally, IBM had the same virtually the same technology that Google had at the time, but they weren't focused on search -- they just thought it was interesting technology.

And let me add, if this is so incremental, I'd love to Google just turn this feature on. Let me ask it any question and just have it return the answer. at the top of the results page w/o me having to click a link. I don't think we'll be seeing that from Google any time soon.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: