Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is it? What ideology was that? It seemed to me like people were legitimately taken in by her. At least, that's what I got from reading Bad Blood. It didn't seem like there was any particular unifying ideology of the investors/believers in Theranos. Some people seemed to like it for its female empowerment narrative, maybe, but I don't think that was a major component for most of the prominent people involved.


Ideology is another word for narrative, and Holmes worked very hard to sell a narrative where she was a disruptive genius who would revolutionise [stale old thing that needed to be disrupted] by sheer force of will and outstanding talent.

Does that narrative not sound a little familiar?

Being a woman genius took it to another level.

It's possible Holmes actually sold the narrative to herself at least as much as she sold it to everyone else.

(But that's not an unfamiliar story either.)

The worrying thing is that Holmes blanked out legitimate criticism. Perhaps she even labelled legitimate critics as haters.

That's an overtly cult-like move. Outsiders who are not aligned with the goal of the cult - often powered by a cult of personality - are dismissed, when in fact their criticisms are realistic and appropriate.

In fact what makes fanboys and haters so annoying is obsessive irrationality. They're noisy, but worryingly content-free.

But not everyone is irrational, and both outsiders and insiders may have valid and considered non-obsessive opinions. Those opinions may be positive, or they may be critical - both for perfectly valid reasons.


Ideology is another word for narrative

But it's not?

I mean I guess there is some kind of relationship - ideologies usually have some kind of story that goes with them.

But a narrative in itself isn't an ideology.

But I do agree that Holmes was able to project a "reality distortion field" in the same way Jobs could. I think that's different to ideology though.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: