Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Are my christmas lights that I put on during winter also everyone else's problem because they waste energy (that I bought with my own money)? Are you going to get into my business there as well and tell me what I can and cannot spend my resources on, because you claim that they have an "impact on you and you have no interest in them"?

I am pretty sure that the best consensus the western world has come up with is that if there are any externalities, they can simply be taxed in like for example a carbon tax. But telling other people what they should and should not find valueable as if you have some sort of ultimate authority on knowing what is valueable, well, I hope you can already see what is wrong with that. Value is subjective. As in, other people have a right to decide for themselves.



> Are my christmas lights that I put on during winter also everyone else's problem because they waste energy (that I bought with my own money)?

Yes but too little to bother about. Transportation and inefficient heat management are the only common ones that matter.

> they can simply be taxed in like for example a carbon tax

On that we agree. I believe car fuel is taxed appropriately in the UK, but in general these externalities are not properly accounted for. If they were, it would be a different matter, but they’re not.


People bought the energy with their own money, it's their own business what to do with it. Ie, not your business.

Also christmas lights do consume huge amounts of electricity comparable to energy budgets of some countries. https://www.igs.com/energy-resource-center/energy-101/how-mu...


Until and unless the carbon taxes are in place, it is everyone’s business.

Thank you for the link, I will now update my world model to include that data.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: