Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

From the bug report that started this thread:

http://www.ntppool.org is not http://pool.ntp.org

and

https://citibank.com.sg is not https://www.citibank.com.sg

and

https://m.tumblr.com/ is not https://www.tumblr.com/

Yet Google makes them all appear to be the same.

There are lots of other odd filtering behaviors in the issue if you want to check out the comments

For example, should:

www.www.www.subdomain.www.www.www.domain.com show as subdomain.domain.com

How is that right?

How does making those two destinations appear to be the same thing make the user "safer" under any stretch of the imagination?



I'm not arguing for Chrome's implementation. I'm saying we should do the more useful but harder thing of just not using "www" as a thing in browser URLs. They have correctly identified it as redundant, but instead tried to fix it by being too clever.

As I mention elsewhere, the first two are bad examples. (In fact. ntppool.org and www.ntppool.org are the same thing.) The third is a hack from the era where responsive design, browser sniffing, and polyfills didn't exist. It should probably die too, but doesn't have to here. The m.tumblr.com name is distinct from tumblr.com and is of the form I think better. Note that they didn't use www.m.tumblr.com.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: