Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Will a wink suffice? How about a photograph or a song?

Edit: Language is fascinating, of course. However, I find the underlying mental layers that support it to be equally fascinating, if not more so.




Are they claims about the world or just expressions?


What's the difference?


A wink is just an expression we call a wink. We can then analyze what a wink it philosophically and make claims about it. So one is the experienced phenomena the other is inquiring about that phenoma.


Can't it be argued that the expression itself is a claim about the state of the world (= "the thing I just said was in jest").


It can but then you are back to subjective interpretation.

You can wink, that wink can have meaning or it's just a wink or you got something in your eye. How do you determine what it is without having used language somehow to establish what a wink could mean? And that's just on the surface of the amgiguity.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: