Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> If Trump weren't President, this action would not have happened.

Source? Because you likely don't have some magical crystal ball, which means you're just 'hoping' that whoever won the election in Sangermaine's alternate universe would have let this ride.

No one in the previous administration had the spine to make Net Neutrality permanent, and you can't hide that no mattery how much gloss you throw at it. Keep dreaming, buddy!



Your comment does not demonstrate an accurate recollection of history nor the stances of the candidates.

Clinton would not have repealed Net Neutrality. Keeping Net Neutrality was one of the Democratic platform planks. So right there, we know that this action would not have happened.

Second, the idea that no one in the Obama administration wanted to make Net Neutrality permanent is absolutely idiotic. The only way something like that could be made permanent would be through an Act of Congress. And the opposition party controlled Congress, so you're not getting that to happen.

Honestly, given your deliberate misunderstanding of the issues, it's probably best you don't vote. Let the adults make the decisions.


> Let the adults make the decisions.

Yea, because personal attacks are SUCH a grown-up, mature thing to do. Stay classy, fellow HN user.


Pointing out the error of your post is not a personal attack.


> No one in the previous administration had the spine to make Net Neutrality permanent

The previous administration spent all their political capital passing Obamacare. After that, they lost the house and senate and were stonewalled at every opportunity by Mitch "Let's make him a one term President" McConnell.


> Source? Because you likely don't have some magical crystal ball

We don't need a crystal ball, we have the statements of the candidates during the election. Trump was, from the beginning, anti-Net Neutrality. As for Clinton:

2015: >Hillary Clinton is vowing to enforce strong net neutrality rules if she is elected president....

“Closing these loopholes and protecting other standards of free and fair competition — like enforcing strong net neutrality rules and preempting state laws that unfairly protect incumbent businesses — will keep more money in consumers’ wallets, enable startups to challenge the status quo, and allow small businesses to thrive,” she wrote in an op-ed in Quartz.

http://thehill.com/policy/technology/257569-clinton-touts-ne...

2016, during the election:

>Hillary Clinton has indicated support for net neutrality. She gave two thumbs up to FCC chairman Tom Wheeler’s proposal for strong net neutrality rules, though admitted it was only a “foot in the door.” Clinton has expressed concern that regulations could mean stagnant competition among service providers, saying “we’ve got to do more about how we incentivize competition in broadband.” And she’s committed to fighting broadband monopolies, citing Google Fiber in Kansas City as a perfect example of what she wants to see everywhere in the US.

https://gizmodo.com/the-2016-presidential-candidates-views-o...

2016, after the election:

>Hillary Clinton gave a shout-out to a Democratic commissioner on the Federal Communications Commission for her rallying call to "raise a ruckus" to save net neutrality, which the Republican-led FCC is poised to dismantle next month.

>"Time to call foul. Time to raise a ruckus. Time to save #NetNeutrality," Jessica Rosenworcel, one of two Democrats on the five-commissioner FCC, tweeted Wednesday.

>In response, Clinton tweeted: "You go girl! This is important; costs will go up, & powerful companies will get more powerful. We can’t let it slip through the cracks"....

>Net neutrality was not a major issue often brought up during the 2016 campaign. However, Clinton, who served as former President Barack Obama's first secretary of state, has shown support for net neutrality in the past. She said she would vote for it back in 2015, calling it a "foot in the door," and characterizing it as a starting point in the broader Internet regulation discussion.

http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/hillary-clinton-we-cant-le...

It's simply a statement of fact that the FCC would not be repealing Net Neutrality right now, or ever, under a Clinton administration. You can argue about the nature of Clinton's support for NN, but she has always consistently voiced support for the policy.

You've so committed to your fantasy of both sides being the same that you've become unhinged from reality.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: