Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You could actually use this analysis technique to fingerprint composers who've ghostwritten for bands, no? Bands pumping out music exactly as compressible are likely the same songwriter, whether they acknowledge that or not.


Composers' identities are rarely a secret, because there are separate royalty streams for performance and composition. OK, pop fans may lean towards the assumption that their idols' songs are always deep personal confessions but there isn't some grand conspiracy to conceal the facts of authorship from the public. Most people just don't think about it very much.


Rarely a secret, yes. But it's not like there's a public database of composer:song mappings anywhere†, for you to easily feed your ML algorithm; you'd have to do a bunch of original research to build that dataset. If there's some statistical way to infer the data with nearly the same quality, so that you don't need to go to the effort of building the dataset yourself, that'd be nice.

† An assumption on my part—is there, in fact, a place where you can look up who gets each portion of the royalties for a given song?


I like to fact-check my assertions prior to making them, unless I'm being metaphysical. Not snark; it's just a huge time saver.

There are a bunch of such datasets, some commercial but accessible for a small fee (like ASCAP), others freely available. I personally like the Discogs one best but some of the commercial offerings are better curated.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_online_music_databases


Wikipedia does a great job of listing credited song writers, from what I've seen. Just check out the detail in a Beyonce or Maroon 5 album. It's like a public CV.

Edit: I just looked up a Maroon 5 album, "Overexposed" and found a few credits to M. Martin. So I clicked on "Daylight." M. Martin. Max Martin.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: