Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Help Revive Hitchbot, the Canadian Robot that Americans Destroyed (thehacktory.org)
18 points by abustamam on Aug 4, 2015 | hide | past | favorite | 10 comments


Please don't lump all "Americans" into the group that destroyed this robot. There are assholes in every country, and that doesn't excuse them. It also isn't a reason to be bigoted against everyone in a very very large country.


It's not like the hacktory isn't in America too. I wonder why they gave their blog post such an inflammatory title...


Sorry, I didn't mean to generalize Americans (as I am one myself). Unfortunately, the few bad people spoil things for the many good people whose songs go unsung.


>Please don't lump all "Americans" into the group that destroyed this robot. There are assholes in every country

The 'all "Americans"' didn't destroy the robot, they're just fertile ground for the assholes who did. It like 'all Muslims' aren't terrorists, they just fertile ground for terrorists.


Assuming the OP wasn't changed, this title breaks the HN guidelines. Please don't use the title field of HN submissions to editorialize. This was a bad case since the provocation derailed the discussion immediately.


Sorry! I'll keep that in mind next time.


So, this is the sad yet inevitable outcome that we've known about from Sci-Fi for some time. When you combine the darker side of human nature and anthropomorphized robots that cannot defend themselves, malicious vandalism and destruction is a given.

The philosophical question remains - when does it cross over from being classified as destruction of property to something like assault.


> When you combine the darker side of human nature and anthropomorphized robots

People have been defacing and destroying property since forever, regardless of what it looks like.

> when does it cross over from being classified as destruction of property to something like assault.

When it becomes sentient and capable of protesting whatever is happening to it?

Whoever did that to the robot would shit a brick if the robot started screaming.


> Whoever did that to the robot would shit a brick if the robot started screaming.

I would assume so, but the robot looked vaguely humanoid, with a smiley face and all. Someone of a sane mind should feel bad defacing such a thing, but seeing as they didn't, they perhaps wouldn't have batted an eye if it had started screaming.

Now if it had pulled a gun, on the other hand...


It would have been destroyed in Boston anyways [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007_Boston_bomb_scare




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: