Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | freespeechlefts's commentslogin

Free speech as you understand it is an american thing. More specifically, it's a popularized and idealized version of free speech that has no basis in reality or law. All free speech rights around the world are defined by governments, culture, law and history. Germany's free speech is markedly different from american free speech for obvious reasons.

Also, you are mistaken when you link free speech to human beings. Corporations have free speech rights. Corporations aren't human beings.

In the idealized abstract, it feels like free speech is a universal and agreed upon ideal. It isn't. Not between nations. Not even within nations. Even in the US, we have no set definition of free speech. Free speech spans from absolutists who believe all speech is legal to those who want to limit free speech to the absolute minimum as they define it.


> Germany's free speech is markedly different from american free speech for obvious reasons.

Germany does not have free speech so yes it is markedly different.

> Corporations have free speech rights. Corporations aren't human beings.

I'm not talking about any legal framework around free speech. If I was, I'd be talking about the First Amendment or about a specific law or court case.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: