Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> When I see a family of 5 my first thought is "holy fuck they must be loaded.

This is an interesting divide between social media reality of children and the real world.

Any parent will recognize that having 5 kids does not mean paying 5X the cost of infant daycare, which is obvious when you think about it. Infant daycare is expensive but it's also temporary.

It's also fascinating that so many people assume daycare is the only option. With 5 kids, having a parent stay home or work part time is fine. You can also hire a nanny. Many of my friends do a nanny share where two families split the cost of a nanny to watch both of their kids together. I have friends who took jobs working offset schedules for a while. Many people move closer to parents who are able to help (not an option for everyone, obviously).

It's also not the end of the world to take a couple years off work. It's a hurdle, but not the end of the road. Many people do it.

I think many childless people who don't spend a lot of time with parents or families become fixated on the infant phase. They see high infant care costs, sleepless nights, changing diapers, and imagine that's what parenting is like. In reality, it's a very short phase of your life.



> You can also hire a nanny.

Yes, or just have your servants watch them.

Most families in the US can't afford a nanny. Daycare is already stretching it.

> It's also not the end of the world to take a couple years off work. It's a hurdle, but not the end of the road. Many people do it.

Mostly women, and that helps keep the gender pay gap going.


> Most families in the US can't afford a nanny. Daycare is already stretching it.

Where are you at?

Nannies are cheaper than daycare starting at 1 kid and the cost becomes overwhelming in favor of a nanny when there's multiple kids. You can also have the nanny watch other kids in the neighborhood if you only have 1 kid.


Paying someone to watch your children full time so that you can do your full time job is inherently classist. Who takes care of the nannies kids?

The solution to "kids are expensive" being to just pay someone lower class to do it is absurd.

> You can also have the nanny watch other kids in the neighborhood if you only have 1 kid.

You're re-inventing daycare here.


> Who takes care of the nannies kids?

Nannies take multiple children (up to 4 here in France) at the same time. So he/she can take his/her own.


Also they only need to be nannied for a couple years, so there's like 48-40 other years of their lives where they can spend the bulk of their focus on the kid they're nannying instead of their own.


The solution to "my garbage is piling up on the street" being to just pay a garbage person to remove it is absurd.


Not to mention, what is the point of having kids if you are just going to pay someone else to raise them?


Just because something is classist doesn't mean its not an economically viable option for a large group of people.


It's classist that I have to work every day and the owners of capital do not, so what?

There is nothing morally wrong with hiring someone to do labor for you.


>Where are you at?

There are two ways to hire a nanny. The "law abiding as a point of pride" way is comically expensive.

The "pay your neighbor's teenager cash" way is cheap.

If even that's too expensive for you then send your kids to whatever unlicensed, uninsured, unregulated daycare that some tradesman's wife runs out of her house.


OP's comment was so wild, I can't believe it was anything but disguised sarcasm.

> Have a parent stay at home and not work

> Hire a nanny

> Move (presumably farther away from your job) closer to your (assumed idle) parents so they can help

> Take a couple of years off of work

These options are available to a vanishingly small percentage of working people, at least in the USA. OP must know this, so why even mentions these outlandish options?


Well, when millions of women started working in the 60s and 70s, do you think it decreased or increased salaries as a whole?


I'm expecting a kid in Jan. It was sort of unexpected (earlier than planned by about a year!). I'm gonna be honest I had a really grim talk with my partner about finances... I don't make tech money right now and my partner is not in a high paid field.

You make good points and I'm looking into all those options now. I have friends who are doing basically everything you mentioned between them.

I do think you missed the extra housing cost associated with children though. It seems like many families simply move out of the urban core when it's time to start or grow their family.


Congrats. Take care with the money, as always, but kids are the most rewarding “investment” imaginable.


I'm sorry dude, but you are clearly part of the 1%. No one I know can afford any of what you're suggesting. "Just take a sabbatical and put up the nanny in your guesthouse!"


My $0.02 is being a mom sucks.

In modern relationships, men just want to work and come home to a cooked meal and clean house, but their wives are working just as many hours the men are. Having kids means tension in relationship, unpaid labor by the woman, and stress parenting kids. Even if the husband steps up, he still can't breast feed for 3 hours per day.

Pregnancy is really terrible on the woman's body. Post-partem disorders, child birth problems, its just not nice.

Then when you finally get back to your career after 3 months - 5 years, you're passed on promotions, you're n-months behind your peers, and you just don't have the time to hustle for a promotion if you're time is consumed raising kids.

Or if you choose not to have kids, you get financially rewarded for your time. You get more professional responsibility and career development. You get external validation for your hard work (bonuses, promotions, etc). You get full control of your own money, without needing to budget with your partner. You get to live in a better location, because smaller places are more affordable near your work. You don't have a 1+ hour commute to your job.

Being a mom just sucks.


You've just reposted this again




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: