Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> but trying to dispute that the Tea Party was founded and fueled by an intense racism laser focused on Barack & Michelle Obama

The statement I replied to was:

> It was a visceral emotional response to the most powerful man on earth being a black man.

This isn’t true. The racists you’re describing were (literally) dying out by the time Obama was elected. The resurgence of white identity politics in America was a reaction to a series of riots (e.g. Ferguson, Baltimore, Kenosha, Seattle, Minneapolis), affirmative action policies in higher education as well as in the public and private sectors, and renewed activity in the grievance industry (e.g. Anita Sarkeesian, Ibram Kendi, etc.).



> The racists you’re describing were (literally) dying out by the time Obama was elected. The resurgence of white identity politics in America was a reaction to a series of riots

This is both inaccurately describing the protests and also way off on timing – for example, Ferguson was 2014 but the white identity politics was on display before the first time he was elected.


> Ferguson was 2014

Obama was president in 2014.

> but the white identity politics was on display before the first time he was elected.

Among klansmen. These are the people I alluded to who were dying out. Young people and the general public at large didn’t take interest in these movements until the summer of 2015, and even then it was just a thing for the terminally-online until the latter half of Biden’s presidency.

There were plenty of off ramps throughout this whole period, leftists opted not to take them because they were operating under the assumption that they would be in control forever.


> Obama was president in 2014.

Yes, and had been since 2009. I’m still not sure how you expect the racist backlash starting in 2008 to have been triggered by time travelers from 2014. People were threatening to lynch him before he was sworn in and the mainstream Republican Party leaders weren’t willing to give those people the treatment David Duke got in the 90s - McConnell tried to spin all of that “one term president” talk as solely about policy but all of the context made it quite clear that they wouldn’t have been so motivated for, say, Kerry.


> the racist backlash starting in 2008

I’m denying that this was a significant force in American politics until the latter half of Obama’s presidency. These people existed; they were not influential.

> McConnell tried to spin all of that “one term president” talk as solely about policy but all of the context made it quite clear that they wouldn’t have been so motivated for, say, Kerry.

What context are you referring to? Would you attribute black Republicans like Condoleezza Rice and Colin Powell to political tokenism intended to appeal to black voters? I know that the prevailing sentiment (among the media I consumed back then, anyways) was that George Bush was a racist who hated black and brown people, but looking back, I just don’t see it. That element of American society doesn’t look influential until the late 2010s and early 2020s when Thiel started buying his way in, and by that point it’s an entirely different cohort.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: