Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> So? Are you implying that this makes it less important?

OP claimed Dragon Ball is universal and transcendent. I'm merely nitpicking that it is not. Same as I would with barbie.

> there's nothing wrong with that either.

Didn't say there was.

> Gender doesn't matter in this context.

Well it is relevant because you just admitted Barbie is female centric.

> Gender has blown up as this big divisive, team sports thing recently, and honestly it's starting to become annoying and hurtful

Yes, and that's why I asked what is the response to my comment.

> It's okay for something to cater to a predominantly male or female audience.

Yes, I agree. That's why I pointed out that different manga genres exist. And no one refuted this point.

> There's nothing wrong with that, and there never has been.

I agree.

> There's nothing here to be offended about.

Exactly. I wasn't making any criticism nor was I offended about it. I was tunnel visioned on the philosophical point of something being universal and transcendent. It's everyone else who had a knee jerk reaction to my comment being some kind of gender criticism



> OP claimed Dragon Ball is universal and transcendent

No he wrote:

> Dragon Ball transcends cultures, languages, and generations like few creative works I can think of do.

Nowhere did he say it is universal or that it transcends gender in anyway. You are arguing against nothing here.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: