Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

He’s talking about the US military. Why would they be in Ukraine or Israel?


Neither Ukraine nor Israel have reached this hypothetical technological era in which a draft is not required, and those facts are inescapable to any American in those countries observing it.

One reason the US military doesn't need a draft is because its proxy forces which are supplied by US equipment do have a military draft.

This is not a complex argument nor are there any facts which are not mutually agreed upon by all parties here.

I'm not able to follow the ideological contortions that would be required to not understand something as simple as:

"The US supplies the equipment, and the local US-backed government uses a draft to supply its army with the number of soldiers it needs to use the equipment."


Well, there is the thing where the US has a massive army even without a draft. They’d need to fight some near equal opponent to ever get to the point where their professional army needs to be supplemented.

Though I don’t disagree with the premise that we’re still far away from purely AI warfare.


>Neither Ukraine nor Israel have reached this hypothetical technological era in which a draft is not required,

They have worse equipment and a much smaller professional army.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: