Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

In Poland you're only required to report a crime if you're a civil servant and the crime is related to your job.


Here in Norway there are special provisions for tax fraud and money laundering. It doesn't apply to "normal" crime only those. But it does apply for everyone not just civil servants.


So if for example I know that my uncle is not paying all his taxes I'm a criminal too unless I report him? Or is it only for bigger frauds?


Yes if the government can prove that you knew about it without telling, you can be charged with it.


>> So if for example I know that my uncle is not paying all his taxes I'm a criminal too unless I report him? Or is it only for bigger frauds?

> Yes if the government can prove that you knew about it without telling, you can be charged with it.

That's not generally true. In the vast majority of cases, simply knowing about a crime and not reporting it is not a crime in itself. You only become liable when you aid-and-abet or join in a conspiracy to commit the crime.

However, it depends very much on the specific crime. Tax evasion may be entirely different than say selling drugs.


Yes, it's specific to tax evasion and money laundering.


Here in North America, you just donate 2% of your ill gotten gains to your local Congressperson!


Doesn't US have an "ill gotten gains" field on the tax form?

EDIT: Apparently, your illegal income is regularly taxable, and expenses related to (most) illegal activity are tax-deductible. Cool!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_of_illegal_income_in_....

"The U.S. Supreme Court in Tellier reiterated that the purpose of the tax code was to tax net income, not punish unlawful behavior."

I do appreciate this sentiment. Separation of concerns.


The U.S. revenue-side of government isn't encouraging you to start illegal businesses to improve tax receipts, they probably get almost no taxes from that form-box ... it's just much easier later when authorities find out about your illegal activities to convict you of evading taxes that were clearly and easily payable in the past than to convict you of your particular illegal behavior.


Also the case in Canada, to my knowledge. A few years ago, a TV show called the tax agency anonymously, claiming to be drug dealers and asking how to report their earnings. The tax agency person was helpful and cooperative, and said they can't report it to police.


false art. 304




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: